Dead and Living Hope

I recently read some encouraging pages in Karl Barth’s Church Dogmatics. Allow me to share some excerpts with you as we reflect on Christ our wisdom this week. So buckle up, put your theology hat on, and be encouraged as you meditate on God’s way with his people:

The wisdom of Solomon is not a kind of knowledge or worldly shrewdness which has its meaning and purpose in itself, or in the existence of the individual Solomon. On the contrary, the wisdom of Solomon is a public, official wisdom of kingship and government…It consists in a gift which marks the competent judge, the power of discrimination between good and evil, the possession of the criterion which the ruler of a people needs to establish justice and peace in his kingdom. 

Solomon’s justice is shown in the story of 1 King 3: Which of the two women who appear before Solomon’s seat of judgment is the mother of the living child? The answer is—the one who would rather give up the possession of it than sacrifice its life. Solomon judges that she is in the right and to her the child is now awarded. On the other hand, the woman is in the wrong who would rather sacrifice the child’s life than renounce the claim to its possession. 

What is the meaning of this story? In fact it is the people of God who are being judged here. Two mothers, that is, two peoples, are secretly hidden and must again and again be distinguished in its midst. The one cherishes a living, the other a dead hope. But which is the one, which the other people? This question and the divine answer to it is the red thread which runs through the whole of the history of Israel. Does not the people with the dead hope constantly lay claim to have a living hope? Does it not stealthily creep into the possession of this hope, self-confidently refusing to renounce its claim and passing itself off as the true people of God? And how does the other stand, which is the true people of the living hope, but cannot prove its possession? Well, God knows, and King Solomon, endowed by Him with wisdom, will declare, what is good and evil! 

Between the two peoples comes the threat that even the living hope will become dead; there will be an utter end of Israel. The decision might be carried out at once in this terrible way. But the threat of this frightful decision, the sword already drawn against the living child, the threatened destruction of the living hope of Israel, is only Solomon’s means of bringing to light right and wrong in his people, and therefore between the two peoples contained in his people. For now it is shown that the people of the dead hope looks on indifferently at the imminent destruction of the living hope to which it had falsely laid claim and still lays claim. In face of this threat the people of the living hope wills only one thing: may the fulfilment of the hope come to whomsoever it will, may the false pretender enjoy it, so long as it only remains and remains alive. …It is the people of motherly love which loves not itself in the child but the child for its own sake.

This, then, is Solomon’s wisdom. This is how it rules in the midst of God’s people. This is the criterion which it knows and applies—the living child as a question concerning the true mother, the living hope as a question concerning the true people of God. Solomon’s wisdom knows and decides that the true people of God will reveal itself and be known as such in the fact that the living hope in God is dearer to it than its own life. And for that reason it will always retain this hope.

Jesus Christ, who is greater than Solomon (Mt. 12), stands in the midst of the people of God with all the wisdom of Solomon, and indeed as its embodiment. Again, and this time critically, the question is asked: Which is the true mother? Again the threat appears.…Again it is possible-and in the strict sense inevitable that neither is right, i.e., that they are all mothers only of a dead child. Again the wisdom of Solomon, which is divine, pursues a different course. But a greater than Solomon is indeed here. For now the sword is not only drawn. It strikes. The Judge Himself suffers Himself to be both the dead child, the annihilated hope of Israel, and also the true mother bereft of her child, the Israel that has lost all hope. He does so in order that as the sacrificed victim (crucified but risen from the dead on the third day) He may be the living hope which wills to be loved in faith for its own sake, but which rightly belongs to all those who believe, who, like the mother of the child, protest and maintain and desire only that He should live, that He should be always who He is, and who for the sake of this desire are justified.

For all of us there remains the threat, the drawn sword, the sword that has not yet smitten or that smites no longer. The only course open to us all, if we wish to be vindicated and revealed as God’s people, is that of faith in Him, the faith in which He Himself will necessarily be dearer and more precious and more significant for us than any claim and expectation we might have in Him for ourselves, the faith which does not find its object in itself but in Him.

Again, in faith in Him we retain that which we cannot even try to procure for ourselves…: our justification, our membership of the true people of God, and therefore the promise of life for time and eternity. As we subordinate ourselves to Jesus Christ in faith, or rather as He subordinates Himself to us by giving Himself to us as the object of our faith. He is made unto us wisdom…He Himself present with us and making us wise as well.